Neapolitana, puttanesca or amatriciana. If you’re an Italian restaurant and I haven’t eaten at your place, this is what I’m going to order. Firstly to check out your pasta (bought in/home made?) and secondly because these simple kind of sauces leave nowhere to hide. If you’re using poor quality ingredients or mucking around with traditional recipes, I’m gonna know.
For the same reason, in pizza places I’ll order the Margherita. I would love to order a Marinara but outside of Italy you’ll only ever get some abomination with rubbery calamari and prawns on it. A real Marinara (which is a pizza ‘of the fishermen’- the one they would have when they returned from sea and as you can imagine last thing they’d want to eat is seafood) is tomato, oregano, garlic and extra virgin olive oil, but they are as rare as hen’s teeth.
When I order Thai, my litmus test dish is Pad Thai. Again a very simple, street-food dish, but one dependent on good ingredients and a sure hand with seasoning.
Chinese it has to be Ma Po tofu. Is the tofu good quality, does it have enough heat?
French; steak frites and Bernaise sauce. There’s such an art to a good Bernaise.
Spanish-croquettas. When they’re bad they’re like some kind of fast food nugget, when they’re good they transport you.
Vietnamese: Pho there’s deeply complex, layered pho and there’s ‘meat and veg soup’.
So what about you dear blog readers? Do you have litmus test dishes?
October 17, 2012 at 8:00 pm
Oh, my lordy, wordy, YES! May I add Japanese – rice, and miso soup. If you can’t make these well, I don’t even want to eat anything else. And as far as the French selection goes (with which I heartily agree), if the frites, and bread, are no good, then au revoir!
October 17, 2012 at 9:10 pm
Spot on with the Japanese and the French with bread.
October 17, 2012 at 8:59 pm
at any new (to me) cafe i usually have eggs benedict, glad I’m not alone. (Thanks for the new word to add to my scrabble brain). love your work.
October 17, 2012 at 9:09 pm
That’s daring having eggs benedict. I won’t have them until I’m sure the places is spankingly clean and well organised.
October 18, 2012 at 7:05 am
Thai: Green curry! not be too sweet or cloying with too much coconut milk – needs a good balance of salty, sweet, sour. Medium heat for greens, verging on the hot, not too mild or worse, a chunky coconut soup.
Regarding those noodles – I have found a lot of pad Thai too sweet with no balance of tamarind juice. A good pad Thai can make me one happy lady
October 22, 2012 at 2:19 pm
Where would you recommend Ma Po Tofu is best?
It’s interesting with the “marinara” thing – to me, it has always been a simple tomato sauce, but in Australia, it seems to mean full of seafood.. I understand the connection, but it seems a widespread, but simple misunderstanding!
Fried rice – can be so, so awful. Spring, or vietnamese rolls. Can be amazing, or so awful.
October 24, 2012 at 6:07 am
China City in Milton used to do a great Ma Po Tofu. Sichuan Bang Bang in Kenmore too. But not sure about vegetarian versions. (It contains pork mince). Agreed with fried rice. Awful.
November 1, 2012 at 9:59 am
I measure a French patisserie by it’s quiche. Must have the right egginess in both flavour and consistency. It’s amazing how often quiche doesn’t taste of egg! Fresh eggs, not over-cooked and too set is what a good quiche is made off. Good pastry too. Golden and flakey and light. Excellent post!